Top Stories
William Mueller 10_30_08

Multi-million dollar settlement over alleged sex abuse

Story By: Ryan Wilson
Source: KOAA

Published Thu Oct 30, 2008, 07:38 PM MDT
Updated Thu Oct 30, 2008, 07:42 PM MDT

Twenty three men who say they were sexually abused 40-years ago by a brother at a catholic high school in Pueblo, have settled a lawsuit for $4 million.

William Mueller was a music teacher at Roncalli High School. He would allegedly tell students he was conducting an experiment. Mueller would then sedate the students with ether, and sexually abuse them inside the bandroom.

The Pueblo Catholic Diocese and the Marianist Religious Order will pay the settlement. The lawyer for the plaintiffs says the Marianists and the Diocese knew that Mueller had abused children before and that's why they were sued.

But Mueller's never gone to prison, because the statute of limitations expired. "If there's one regret that I have," plaintiff attorney Adam Horowitz said, "It's that William Mueller's still a free man, and he's never been prosecuted criminally."

He says that Mueller lives in San Antonio, Texas, in a trailer park. Bishop Arthur Tafoya released a statement saying "I sincerely hope that this resolution will provide some peace for these men, and also for the people of the Diocese of Pueblo who have been affected."

Horowitz says that about 16 of the men who alleged abuse still live in Pueblo. Roncalli High School is now Roncalli Middle School and is run by the Pueblo City School District.

Top Story Videos

Don't Miss It

Heron at Fountain Creek Nature Center. Photo by Scott Thompson.

Featured Picture

Upload your favorite photo to our website.  Others can see it and your photo may be featured on News First.

Job of the Day
Environmentalist
Ft. Carson
$46,600 - $104,500

Jobs First Colorado

Search for jobs locally and throughout Colorado.

 

News First Vacation

Explore your own beautiful state --
destinations in Colorado.

Weekend on the GO! logo 80x60

Weekend on the GO!

Fireworks Displays 
All over Southern Colorado

 

Special Sections

Wacky Stories

Weird, wild and unusual stories from Colorado Springs and around the world. This stuff truly earns the title “WACKY."

Most Wanted Predators

News First keeps an updated list of Southern Colorado's most wanted sexual predators.  Your anonymous tips can help authorities track them down.

Sponsored Events

Check out the events sponsored by KOAA-TV, News First 5/30.

Teachers First

Honor that special person who inpires kids to learn and grow. Nominate him or her for this monthly award from News First.

 

Gas Tracker

Find the cheapest gas in Southern Colorado.  Gas Tracker is simple, interactive and always up-to-date.

Connect With Kids

Tough topics about kids and teens. Research-based parenting tips, teacher info, and news about kids.

Check For Life

News First has joined the fight against Breast Cancer. Click here to find out where to get your Check for Life kit.